| Score | Name | Season | Grade |
| 219* | Nathan Hawkes | 2012/2013 | Kookaburra Sports / Turner Shield Senior Division |
| 188 | Ben Jordan | 2007/2008 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 178 | Chris Spinella | 2014/2015 | Patrick Quinn Shield Senior Seconds |
| 175* | Daniel O'Connell | 2015/2016 | Patrick Quinn Shield Senior Seconds |
| 174 | Jason Bourke | 2012/2013 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 172 | Henry W Jaggard | 2017/2018 | North/West 4th XI Division 1 |
| 165 | Andre Noonan | 1990/1991 | VJCA North B |
| 165 | Sahil Sharma | 2019/2020 | North/East 2nd XI |
| 164* | Chris Spinella | 2016/2017 | North/East 1st XI |
| 159 | Jack L Sterland | 2015/2016 | Kookaburra Sports / Turner Shield Senior Division |
| 155 | Luke Marinelli | 2018/2019 | North/East 2nd XI |
| 151 | Warren Allison | 1992/1993 | VJCA North D |
| 148* | Patrick O'Connell | 2014/2015 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 146* | Anthony Jordan | 2012/2013 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 140 | Gregory Garth | 2007/2008 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 138* | James Davey | 2012/2013 | Patrick Quinn Shield Senior Seconds |
| 137* | Paul Huxley | 1997/1998 | VTCA – North E |
| 136* | Chris Spinella | 2021/2022 | North/East 1st XI |
| 135* | Paul Hughes | 1987/1988 | VJCA North B |
| 135* | Sean Hefter | 2020/2021 | North/West 4th XI Division 1 |
| 134 | Michael Redmond | 1988/1989 | VJCA North A |
| 134 | Duncan Snell | 2009/2010 | Kookaburra Sports / Turner Shield Senior Division |
| 129 | Jason Bourke | 2018/2019 | North/West 3rd XI Division 1 |
| 127 | Ryan Scarborough | 2013/2014 | Vic Beddome Shield C2 |
| 125* | Andre Noonan | 2002/2003 | Vic Beddome Shield C2 |
| 125* | Travis Carrick | 2007/2008 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 125* | Nicholas Rule | 2010/2011 | North C4 - 1 Day Saturday |
| 125 | Ivan Jurcic | 2010/2011 | North C4 - 1 Day Saturday |
| 124* | Simon Lambert | 2015/2016 | Kookaburra Sports / Turner Shield Senior Division |
| 124 | Rick Cullinan | 1998/1999 | VTCA North A |
| 123* | Paul Fitzgerald | 2002/2003 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 123 | Anthony Jordan | 2019/2020 | North/West 4th XI Division 1 |
| 122* | Steve Harty | 2004/2005 | Vic Beddome Shield C2 |
| 122 | Andrew Boag | 2003/2004 | Fred Jamieson Shield Division 2 Seconds |
| 122 | Arosh Janoda | 2018/2019 | North/East 1st XI |
| 120* | Nicholas Serrano | 2000/2001 | VTCA North D1 3rd XI |
| 120 | Michael Redmond | 1985/1986 | VJCA North A |
| 119 | Chris Wade | 1986/1987 | VJCA North B |
| 119 | Michael Davis | 1990/1991 | VJCA North A |
| 119 | Travis Carrick | 2006/2007 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 119 | Sean Hefter | 2016/2017 | North/West 3rd XI Division 1 |
| 118* | Brian Dillon | 1968/69 | CYMS - A Grade |
| 118* | Chris Spinella | 2018/2019 | North/East 1st XI |
| 118 | Anthony Jordan | 1993/1994 | VJCA Senior Div 2nd XI |
| 118 | Jason Bourke | 2015/2016 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 117* | Tony Isaacs | 1985/1986 | VJCA North B |
| 117 | Julian Kennelly | 1982/1983 | VJCA North A |
| 116 | Michael Redmond | 1991/1992 | VJCA Senior Div |
| 116 | Paul Hughes | 1993/1994 | VJCA 3rd XI North D |
| 116 | Andre Noonan | 2005/2006 | Fred Jamieson Shield Division 2 Seconds – Semi Final |
| 116 | Michael Wheaton | 2015/2016 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 115 | Paul Hughes | 1984/1985 | VJCA 3rd XI |
| 115 | Andre Noonan | 1996/1997 | VTCA Senior A |
| 114* | Kevin Phelan | 1975/1976 | VJCA North A |
| 114* | Michael Laidler | 1987/1988 | VJCA North A |
| 114* | Sean Hefter | 2020/2021 | North/West 4th XI Division 1 |
| 114 | Anthony Jordan | 2011/2012 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 114 | Chris Spinella | 2017/2018 | North/East 1st XI |
| 114 | Arosh Janoda | 2017/2018 | North/East 1st XI |
| 113* | Tristan Kassis | 2020/2021 | North/East 1st XI |
| 113 | Michael Redmond | 1986/1987 | VJCA North A |
| 113 | Patrick O'Connell | 2014/2015 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 113 | Tim J Grant | 2016/2017 | North/East 1st XI |
| 113 | James Browne | 2016/2017 | North/West 4th XI Division 1 |
| 112* | Travis Carrick | 2006/2007 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 112 | Jason Bourke | 2012/2013 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 112 | Tim Raffle | 2014/2015 | Patrick Quinn Shield Senior Seconds |
| 111* | Liam Jilla | 2007/2008 | North C4 - 1 Day Saturday |
| 111* | John Jordan | 2008/2009 | North C4 - 1 Day Saturday |
| 110 | David Norton | 1979/1980 | VJCA – North A |
| 110 | Steve Harty | 2004/2005 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 109* | Julian Kennelly | 1984/1985 | VJCA – North A |
| 109* | Anthony Garvey | 2002/2003 | Fred Jamieson Shield Division 2 Seconds |
| 109 | Terry Davis | 1981/1982 | VJCA – North A |
| 109 | Antonio Mullins | 2008/2009 | Senior A1 – Semi Final |
| 109 | James Salamito | 2021/2022 | North/West 3rd XI Division 2 |
| 108* | Henry W Jaggard | 2021/2022 | North/West 4th XI Division 2 |
| 108 | Harry Overman | 2008/2009 | North C4 - 1 Day Saturday |
| 107* | Ross Rodgers | 1997/1998 | VTCA – North E – Grand Final |
| 107* | Craig Osborne | 2002/2003 | Western Sports Centre / McNamara Shield Division 2 |
| 107* | Jason Bourke | 2011/2012 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 107 | Michael Laidler | 1986/1987 | VJCA – North A |
| 107 | Sean A Bolger | 2014/2015 | Just Energy / Ken Eastwood Shield C3 (Sat One Day) |
| 106* | John Harvey | 1974/1975 | VJCA – North C - 2nd XI |
| 106* | Paul Hedley | 1983/1984 | VJCA North A |
| 106* | Matthew Bergin | 2012/2013 | Patrick Quinn Shield Senior Seconds |
| 106 | Paul Huxley | 1991/1992 | VJCA Senior Div |
| 106 | Paul Williams | 1994/1995 | VTCA 3rd XI North D |
| 106 | Jordan Mills | 2021/2022 | North/East 2nd XI |
| 105* | Michael Laidler | 1988/1989 | VJCA North A |
| 105* | John Jordan | 2002/2003 | Vic Beddome Shield C2 |
| 105 | James Maynard | 1993/1994 | VTCA 3rd XI North D |
| 105 | Henry W Jaggard | 2016/2017 | North/West 3rd XI Division 1 |
| 104 | John Tobin | 1968/1969 | CYMS - A Grade |
| 104 | Tony Isaacs | 1986/1987 | VJCA North B |
| 104 | Phillip Conlan | 1986/1987 | Metropolitan Cricket League 3rd XI |
| 104 | Craig Osborne | 1998/1999 | VTCA North E |
| 104 | Brad Maiden | 2001/2002 | VTCA Vic Beddome Shield North C2 |
| 104 | Gregory Garth | 2008/2009 | Senior North 2nds |
| 104 | Paul Grant | 2021/2022 | Glenn Scarborough Shield D2 Sunday One Day |
| 103* | Michael Perrett | 1970/1971 | CYMS – A Grade 2nd XI |
| 103* | John O’Connell | 1983/1984 | VJCA – 3rd XI |
| 103* | Nathan Hawkes | 2010/2011 | Kookaburra Sports / Turner Shield Senior Division |
| 103* | John Jordan | 2014/2015 | Just Energy / Ken Eastwood Shield C3 (Sat One Day) |
| 103 | Steven McLeod | 1989/1990 | VJCA North B |
| 103 | Andrew Boag | 2002/2003 | Fred Jamieson Shield Division 2 Seconds - Semi Final |
| 103 | Craig Osborne | 2003/2004 | Western Sports Centre / McNamara Shield Division 2 |
| 103 | Benjamin J Ackland | 2013/2014 | Kookaburra Sports / Turner Shield Senior Division |
| 102* | Gregory Garth | 2007/2008 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 102* | Sean Hefter | 2014/2015 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 102* | Tim J Grant | 2016/2017 | North/East 1st XI |
| 102 | Paul Fitzgerald | 2001/2002 | VTCA Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 102 | Michael Vallence | 2007/2008 | Fred Jamieson Shield Division 2 Seconds |
| 102 | Luke Marinelli | 2021/2022 | North/West 3rd XI Division 2 – Grand Final |
| 101* | Terry Davis | 1975/1976 | VJCA North A |
| 101* | Terry Davis | 1982/1983 | VJCA North A |
| 101* | Terry Davis | 1984/1985 | VJCA North A |
| 101* | Gregory Garth | 2013/2014 | Just Energy / Ken Eastwood Shield C3 (Sat One Day) |
| 101* | Brendan Davey | 2018/2019 | North/West 3rd XI Division 1 |
| 101 | John Harvey | 1972/1973 | CYMS - A Grade |
| 101 | Andre Noonan | 2005/2006 | Fred Jamieson Shield Division 2 Seconds |
| 101 | Jason Bourke | 2007/2008 | Fred Jamieson Shield Division 2 Seconds |
| 101 | James Davey | 2017/2018 | North/East 2nd XI |
| 101 | Chris Spinella | 2018/2019 | North/East 1st XI |
| 100* | Michael Thom | 2000/2001 | VTCA North D1 3rd XI |
| 100* | Michael Knight | 2000/2001 | VTCA North D2 4th XI |
| 100* | Matthew Shannon | 2000/2001 | VTCA Frank Keon Shield C1 |
| 100* | Jason Bourke | 2004/2005 | Fred Jamieson Shield Division 2 Seconds |
| 100* | Jason Bourke | 2005/2006 | Fred Jamieson Shield Division 2 Seconds |
| 100* | Henry W Jaggard | 2021/2022 | North/West 4th XI Division 2 |
| 100 | Peter Monaghan | 1983/1984 | VJCA – 3rd XI |
| 100 | Nicholas Serrano | 2008/2009 | Senior North 2nds |
| 100 | Jason Bourke | 2017/2018 | North/West 3rd XI Division 1 |
| 100 | Jason Bourke | 2010/2011 | Frank Keon Shield C1 |